Dumbbell Empty Can Raise

What Is the Dumbbell Empty Can Raise?
Dumbbell Empty Can Raise is an isolation exercise that primarily targets the shoulders and also engages the rotator cuff and the muscles that rotate the shoulder blades. It is a beginner-level movement done standing with a light dumbbell in each hand, raising straight arms to shoulder height with the arms turned inward so the thumbs point down.
The name comes from the hand position: with the thumbs pointing down, each hand looks as if it is pouring out a can. It is the thumbs-down counterpart to the Dumbbell Full Can Raise, which follows the same path with the thumbs up. Orthopedic surgeon Frank Jobe popularized the position in the early 1980s as a way to load the supraspinatus, the small rotator cuff muscle on top of the shoulder blade that helps start lifting the arm, and clinicians still use the same arm position as a strength test for that muscle, often called the empty can or Jobe test.
Like the full can, it is done in the scapular plane, about 30 degrees forward of straight out to the side, which is the angle the shoulder blade naturally sits at. In a fine-wire EMG study of 22 healthy adults raising a light dumbbell in that plane to shoulder height, the empty can and the full can drew similar supraspinatus activity, while the empty can drew more middle and rear deltoid activity. Turning the arm inward does not single out the supraspinatus, so the deltoid still does most of the lifting, the upper trapezius and serratus anterior rotate the shoulder blade upward, and the infraspinatus and teres minor help keep the ball of the shoulder centered in its socket.
The empty can is one of the more debated shoulder exercises. Turning the arm inward tips the shoulder blade forward as the arm rises, so many physical therapists now prefer the full can for strengthening and keep the empty can mainly as a test position, while others still program it for healthy shoulders as a variation that shifts a little more work to the deltoid. It suits lifters with pain-free shoulders who want to vary their rotator cuff and shoulder work, and it is not a replacement for the Dumbbell Lateral Raise when the goal is bigger side delts, because the load stays light. Anyone who feels pinching in this position can build up with Band Shoulder External Rotation or switch to the full can.
Muscles Worked
- Deltoid
- Primary
- Upper Trapezius
- High
- Infraspinatus
- Medium
- Serratus Anterior
- Medium
- Teres Minor
- Low
- Rhomboid Major
- Minimal
Instructions
- Stand tall with your feet about hip-width apart, holding a light dumbbell in each hand in front of your thighs with your palms facing back.
- Set your shoulders down and away from your ears and brace your midsection lightly so your torso stays still.
- Keep your arms straight with relaxed elbows and your thumbs pointing in toward your body.
- Raise both arms out to the sides and slightly forward, about 30 degrees in front of straight out, keeping the arms turned inward so the thumbs point down toward the floor.
- Lift until your hands reach shoulder height and your arms are about parallel to the floor, without shrugging.
- Pause briefly at the top with your thumbs still pointing down.
- Lower the dumbbells slowly along the same path back to your thighs.
- Breathe out as you lift and in as you lower, and repeat for the planned reps.
Common Mistakes
Shrugging the shoulders
Letting the shoulders rise toward the ears hands the work to the upper trapezius and crowds the top of the shoulder.
Using dumbbells that are too heavy
A heavy load lets the deltoid and traps take over and forces a shrug or a swing, which is when the thumbs-down position is least forgiving.
Raising above shoulder height
Lifting past shoulder height with the arm turned inward drives the top of the arm bone toward the bony roof of the shoulder and adds little to the exercise.
Raising straight out to the sides
Taking the arms directly out in line with the body instead of slightly forward moves the lift out of the scapular plane and makes the inward-turned position less comfortable.
Swinging the torso
Leaning back or bouncing at the knees to get the weights up uses momentum and loads the lower back instead of the shoulder.
Pushing through a pinch
Finishing a set through a pinching feeling at the top of the shoulder ignores the clearest sign that the thumbs-up full can suits that shoulder better right now.
Injuries
Dumbbell Empty Can Raise is a medium risk exercise when performed with proper technique. The load is light and many people with healthy shoulders do it without trouble, but the thumbs-down position makes it the less forgiving of the two can raises.
The concern is the space under the top of the shoulder, where the supraspinatus tendon runs. In a study of 28 people with shoulder impingement, the empty can was rated about one point more painful on a 0 to 10 scale than the thumbs-up full can and held the shoulder blade in less backward tilt and more inward rotation, positions that have been linked to a narrower space under the bony roof of the shoulder. The difference was small and the study looked at painful shoulders, so it shows the empty can is the worse choice for an irritated shoulder rather than that it injures a healthy one.
The usual strain points are the top and front of the shoulder, where a pinching feeling means the weight is too heavy or the arm is going too high, the neck and upper trapezius when the shoulders shrug, and the lower back when the torso swings the weights up. Choose dumbbells light enough to lift with a still body, keep the arms slightly forward of straight out to the side, stop at shoulder height and lower slowly. To make it easier, use no weight, work one arm at a time or stop below shoulder height, or switch to the Dumbbell Full Can Raise or Dumbbell Side-Lying Shoulder External Rotation. To progress, add a pause at the top or slow the lowering phase rather than reaching for heavier dumbbells.
Stop if you feel sharp or pinching pain at the top of the shoulder, especially in the middle of the lift, or pain that is still raised the next day, and move to the full can instead. Night pain, pain at rest, or weakness that keeps you from lifting the arm should be checked by a doctor or physical therapist before you load the shoulder again.
Other Names for the Dumbbell Empty Can Raise
The Dumbbell Empty Can Raise is also known as:
- Dumbbell Empty Can Scaption
Frequently Asked Questions
- Q: Is the empty can exercise bad for your shoulders?
It depends on the shoulder. Turning the arm inward tips the shoulder blade forward and tends to be more painful for people with impingement, so many physical therapists prefer the thumbs-up Dumbbell Full Can Raise for a sore shoulder, while a healthy, pain-free shoulder usually handles it with a light weight.
- Q: How is it different from the full can raise?
Only the hand position changes: the thumbs point down here and up in the full can, along the same path to shoulder height. Both work the supraspinatus about equally, but the empty can brings in more of the middle and rear deltoid and puts the shoulder blade in a position a sore shoulder tolerates less well.
- Q: Is this the same as the empty can test?
It uses the same arm position. In the test, a clinician presses down on the arms held near shoulder height while the person resists, as one check of the supraspinatus, whereas the exercise lifts a dumbbell through the full range for repetitions. Pain or clear weakness in that position is a reason to see a clinician before training it.
- Q: How heavy should the dumbbells be?
Light enough to do 10 to 20 slow reps without shrugging or swinging, which for most people means somewhere around 2 to 5 pounds per hand. Add weight only when the last reps still look clean and the shoulder feels fine the next day.
- Q: Can it replace lateral raises for bigger side delts?
No. It does bring in the middle deltoid, but the light load it needs keeps it from being a good size builder, so the Dumbbell Lateral Raise is the better choice for that goal.
- Q: Where does it fit in a workout?
It works as part of a warm-up before pressing or overhead work, or as a light accessory at the end of an upper body session for 2 to 3 sets. Because the load is small, it adds little fatigue to the rest of the session.




